The key to
handling disappointment is managing expectations. Nobody gets it right all the
time. I was so in love with the previous season of John Ridley’s Emmy-winning
series that I assumed I’d be in for a real treat with season 3. But while there
is some merit (it would be hard for Ridley to completely misfire), the season
is kind of a mess, and not even a hot one, but rather lukewarm.
The third
season takes on abuse and exploitation in its many forms. We have migrant
workers on a tomato farm who have to live a dozen people to a trailer, an
environment rife with peril. They don’t get paid enough to ever move on because
they have to pay for their lavish accommodations, food, and “health care”
(sometimes illegal drugs) out of their low wages. Oh, they’re also beaten,
overworked, raped, and worse. Being a migrant worker is no picnic. Take that,
Mr. President.
The tomato
farm featured here has been run by an old man who is now on his death bed. It
has been taken over by his oldest daughter, a mean-spirited, manipulative
control freak, completely devoid of empathy. When the wife of one of the farm
owners, Jeanette (perennial favorite Felicity Huffman), starts to ask questions
about the welfare of the workers, she is utterly dismissed and made to feel
worthless.
I mentioned
drugs before. Several characters,
including Coy, played by last season’s Connor Jessup, are addicted, and this
addiction is used as a means of control. (And boy, did I want to see more of
Jessup in this, but he was really a more supporting actor here.)
Another form
of exploitation is human trafficking and prostitution. Dedicated and caring
social worker Kimara (played by Regina King, who won Emmys the last two years
for her roles on American Crime) tries very hard to get young men and women out
of this lifestyle before they end up dead or in jail, but for her, it’s always
two steps forward, one step back. On top of that, she is having fertility
treatments to have that baby she’s always wanted. This probably explains her
motherly instinct. She is certainly the most likable character in the show this
season.
Then there
is the French Haitian nanny, Gabriella—played with heartbreaking brilliance by
newcomer Mickaelle Bizet—who was brought to America by an extremely unhappy
couple (Lili Taylor and Timothy Hutton) to watch their son and to be abused. Taylor’s
character is very enigmatic…probably too much so…and Hutton’s character is
simply monstrous.
Most of
these stories are snapshots with little air time. Much is hidden in terms of
what actually happens, with whom, and why. There doesn’t seem to be much reason
for this. A sense of mystery? I call it a sense of confusion. The season is
only 8 episodes long instead of 10 or 11, like before. Thus, there is little
time for story and character development. Every story feels disjointed, in
spite of the fact that there is a loose thread running through each. The story
of the migrants only takes up the first 4 episodes, while the nanny’s story
picks up in its absence for the second half. We get Kimara’s and Jeanette’s
stories through all 8 episodes, perhaps because of the popularity of the two
actresses, but only Kimara’s story is engaging to watch. Jeanette is a doormat
who tries for about a second to become an independent woman, but ends up caving
in the end.
Perhaps the
most emotional story is that of Luis Salazar, played by Benito Martinez, a Latin
American immigrant who has come to look for his missing son. When that story is
resolved in what is really the most intense moment in the series during episode
4, everything that comes after is anticlimactic.
This season’s
themes are overtly political. This is a contrast to what has come before in the
series. Instead of telling a gripping story with amazing, relatable characters
and letting the audience make up its own mind, the producers have taken it upon
themselves to educate the privileged white patriarchy. In doing so, they have
reduced the show from something exceptional to something common.
No comments:
Post a Comment